We’re from the government, we’re here to help

How would you feel if you lived in a remote community in the middle of nowhere, you had no money, no prospects and felt pretty much ignored and forgotten by the rest of the country.  Your life expectancy was about 2/3 the national average; unemployment, alcoholism and abuse were endemic.  Then one day, completely unannounced, the army rolled up and said “The government sent us, we’re here to help.”

Me, I’d be a little freaked out as I recount in this video:

[livevideo id=BB1676895BDF4C3C873DF83438E9776F]

This was the situation faced by some indigenous Australians this week.  You can download an MP3 of a report that includes an interview with a bemused local here.  The rest of the country knew what was going on because it had been a major story in the media but the news travels more slowly in these remote areas.

What it was all about was the federal government’s plan to address a report into the rather appalling state of affairs in many remote indigenous communities.  This issue has been growing in prominence over the last year, I blogged about one of the first major reports last year.  The hot button issues have been alcoholism and child sexual abuse, both of which are widespread problems.

Some of the higher profile government initiatives include banning alcohol and pornography in these communities (that would tip me over the edge, if the army took away my booze and porn).  Even some international media has focused on the banning of substances for a particular race.  It isn’t as if white government in this country has a very good track record with the indigenous population (aborigines were only recognised as part of the population after a referendum in 1967).

The government says that it’s a complete coincidence that there’s an election later this year and they’re lagging badly in the polls.  The fact that they have won previous elections by inventing dramatic issues shouldn’t make you think that’s what they’re doing here.  Their opponents disagree.  Go figure.

The fact that the author of the report is saying the government is taking the wrong approach is rather telling.  However, it’s good to see that the people on the receiving end are keeping an open mind.  I like to think that the people on the ground (police, army, welfare workers) have the best intentions and maybe their good work will rise above any political pointscoring by either side of politics.

If anyone is actually interested in the issue there are a few terms that might pop up that could require some explanation:

Children Overboard: The current federal government has had previous electoral success by whipping up paranoia about illegal immigrants/refugees.  Prior to the 2001 election, the government claimed that a boatload of asylum seekers that had been intercepted by an Australian Navy ship had thrown some of their children overboard in an attempt to force the ship to pick them up.

The claim was proven to be false and it was also found that the government knew the claim was untrue before the election but never passed this bit of information along to the public.  This made them look “strong” (dirty foreigners, they weren’t genuine refugees but they forced us to pick them up) and the opposition look “weak” (they’d let anyone into the country).  Some people are suggesting that the government’s sudden focus on the plight of aboriginal children is similar political game-playing.

The Stolen GenerationThis term refers to previous governmental policies of removing children (usually of mixed descent) from aboriginal communities and making them wards of the state.  This makes some people understandably wary of government intervention regarding their children (there are already stories of families fleeing settlements at the sight of authorities).  Some people say this is the past and should be forgotten.  Considering this happened to people my age and younger this doesn’t seem like ancient history to me.  The government has some work ahead of it to convince indigenous people that this is more than another attempt to take away their right to self-determination.

I take it as a positive sign that there has been strong debate on the topic.  Not everybody is swallowing the government’s line and not everybody is rejecting it out of hand.  I’ll never stop being cynical about politicians of all stripes but whether this is fuelled by politics or by genuine concern for what the Prime Minister has rightly called a “national disaster” there’s at least a chance of a positive outcome.



Filed under Politics, Video Blogging

9 responses to “We’re from the government, we’re here to help

  1. I’ve got to say, that the person who gets to deliver the line “We’re from the government, we’re here to help.” Has probably been waiting his entire life to say that.

    Surely installing decent communications systems, and providing political representation for these isolated communities would possibly help. At least then they’d get to decide for themselves what sort of help they wanted.

  2. I’ve been waiting all my life to say “Stand back- I’m a gynaecologist”…

    but it’s never going to happen…

    I also think that this is an election year stunt pulled by the current government simply to deflect voters from thinking about the “other” things they’ve fucked up.

    I also agree that child abuse is possibly the most abhorent crime there is; Why hasn’t the government done something about it before? Why wait til now to bring it to the fore?

    Little Johnny Limpdick is trying desperately to save face with the Voting Public, but this time, I don’t think it’s going to wash…

  3. I’d also like to say that the indigenous Australians aren’t doing themselves any favours.

    The help is there for them, if they REALLY want it. Instead of standing in the bush with their hands out, they could be doing better things with themselves, and actually go to the free university courses that are on offer just for the aboriginal community, or even finishing highschool would be a good start (as a white australian who didn’t finish year 10, I’m not doing to bad for myself, and that’s without all the A&TSI (Aboriginal and Torre Strait Isalnder) benefits that aren’t available to the rest of the community.

  4. And sure, I’m gonna piss some people off; no matter what I said, someone would dissagree.

    Stiff shit.

    These are my thoughts, and you are welcome to try and change my mind…

  5. Massif: I’m not sure he used those exact words – I was using my imagination

    gruntski: You go mate. The whole thing does reek of an election stunt. Plus, your right in that the aborigines ultimately need to take responsibility for themselves. Hopefully whitefellahs will stop screwing with them and give them a decent chance to.

  6. “Hopefully whitefellahs will stop screwing with them and give them a decent chance to.”
    This is key I think. It’s hard to really want something and go out there and make something of yourself in the face of so much hatred, racism, lethargy, addiction and fear.
    This is an excellent post MA.

  7. Simonne: It’s a subject I find difficult to write about. I do believe that everyone is ultimately responsible for their own actions and there’s never an excuse for child abuse but the situation with indigenous Australians is complicated to say the least.

  8. So complicated that most Australians just don’t want to go there, so again, I admire you for doing so and doing it so well. I agree that we’re responsible for ourselves, but if your personal history is such that you have become an adult with no sense of self worth, belonging, and worthiness, with limited resources, little education, and have suffered abuse yourself, being ‘responsible’ is hardly an easy thing to achieve. My heart aches for so many people in such dire circumstances.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s